Showing posts with label Why do bad things happen to good people. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Why do bad things happen to good people. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Why God Lets Children Get Cancer – Part II


Dear TEAMS,

My last post to you began the discussion of Why Does God Let Bad Things Happen?  In it, I counseled you to really get at the heart of what your hurting friend is really dealing with.  In the end, they need to know you care.

As for the theological/academic answer to that question, I have found it to be brusque and hard but nonetheless Truth.  God does not need to be defended.  I am reminded of the movie A Few Good Men and the dialogue between characters in the courtroom:

Col. Jessep:   You want answers?
Kaffee:   I think I'm entitled to.
Col. Jessep:   You want answers?
Kaffee:   I want the truth!
Col. Jessep:   You can't handle the truth!

The Truth is that God didn’t mess up this world, we did.  He created us with the ability to make powerful choices, and every choice we make in life either creates life or it doesn’t.  Choose to smoke 20 cigarettes a day, and you’ll probably get lung cancer and die from it.  Even if you’re a nice guy, the life of the party, the best friend of everyone you meet.  God, who created magnificent lung tissue that extracts what we cannot see from the air we take in and a body that then distributes those elements all around without our having any control or knowledge of it, entrusted that lung tissue to us for care.  But somehow, the smoker is absolved of all blame when they didn’t hold up their end of the bargain?

God entrusts a person with financial or property wealth and the person thinks of nothing else but to spend it on his own pleasure, so much so that at the end of life, the surplus is gone.  Three generations later, his young, widowed, great-granddaughter who is the sweetest person anyone has ever met would love to be able to buy a house for her children but cannot, and laughs at her situation, wondering what it was like for this unknown ancestor to have enough to get through a day.  And God is blamed that this good woman is in her situation?

Hundreds of years ago, an ancestor wandered into a place of higher naturally occurring radiation, or was incapable of eating a balanced diet, or was a cussed son-of-a-gun and drank himself silly and caused genetic mutation that was carried and built upon throughout time.  Perhaps even more descendants of his made terrible choices as well, adding to the likelihood of DNA damage.  And a young boy born to lovely parents contracts brain cancer at 12 months.  But all of a sudden, there is no anger at stupid choices that there is no proof of, but anger at a God who there is proof of?

Just what exactly ARE we responsible for, if not our choices?  And when we are a victim to one or more person’s bad choices, why aren’t people really focused with their anger at the people who made the bad choices?  And why is it that the people who generally ask these questions don’t entertain the possibility that there have been thousands upon millions of things that they have been spared from because of the very nature of God that they are now calling into question?  

We cannot have it both ways.  We cannot get angry at God for not stopping the drunk driver that killed the newly graduated, responsible high school student but then dismiss away the times we made the bad common sense choices and believe we “got away with it” because we saw nothing bad happen.  Nothing bad happened because of God’s Mercy, not because you are God and made it that way.  Why is it deciding to have unprotected sex that didn’t result in pregnancy or STD (if only that was all there was to it!) is seen as us dodging a bullet, and not an act of God’s mercy?  

Make no mistake; God set up the world to be a place of beauty and compassion and about Him.  Not because He is a self-absorbed, self-centered SOB, but because He has always been, always is, and always will be.  He spoke one word, and life and our world was created, full of mysteries and wonder and beauty that we cannot fathom with our merely human brains.  He set up the laws we live by, both legal and unspoken.  He is the ultimate authority.  But to blame Him, when He is the originator of all we find good in the world?  Is that even logical?  Again, if it’s God’s fault, do you really believe you are walking through this world completely innocent and absolved of blame?

So, how do you reconcile the fact that children get cancer (or insert whatever you wish that is tragic), through no fault of their own?  Well, truly, I think that is the wrong question.  Just think about it logically:

  • Will answering this question keep children from getting cancer ever again?
  • Will answering this question heal the child of his/her cancer?
  • Will you accept the answer if you don’t like it?

Because the answer to the question of why there is evil in the world is that there just is.  We Christians frame it as “we live in a fallen world.”  I defy you to tell me there is not, because I’ve got a whole lotta tangible proof around me.  I have found as I see more of life that the most successful people in life acknowledge the existence of evil, but choose to focus on the abundance of blessings they DO have.  Hence, the Facebook status that realizes the luxury that the worst thing in your life right now is bad traffic, or that people disagree with you politically.

What I finished in my message to my friend on Facebook: 

All I know is that God weeps with us and cares and is walking beside us. He made us strong, and I believe He delights to see us rely on that gift in these hard, character-refining times. He is more there than we know, protecting us from far more than we can see or imagine, and showing new mercies to us every morning.

Love,



Friday, May 25, 2012

Why God Lets Children Get Cancer – Part I


Dear TEAMS,

I was on Facebook yesterday and was posting an observation from one of Daddy’s friends who has a 2-year old son with brain cancer.  They have been battling it over a year, and the child has done the last experimental treatment possible…and the cancer came back.  The child has already had IQ points knocked off because of the brain damage caused by the aggressive chemo treatment that was necessary for the cancer...and now the child has cancer back anyway.  It is heartbreaking.

Anyway, Daddy’s friend said that he wished he had the luxury of being able to make a “normal” Facebook post about the bad traffic or politicians his disagreed with or a passing illness.  That struck me, because most of the people on FB who post those things are unaware that it is a luxury to only have those things to invest their emotional energy into.  So, I posted a status that reflected my observation.

One of the comments I received was from a childhood friend who said, “These are the things I plan to discuss with God someday!”  The comment struck me as odd, because my status was about putting things into perspective.  But upon reflection, I realized her comment reflected the hurt and anger she has at the way things are and seeing people she loves suffer.

I sent her a private message that told her that I cared that she hurt, and that I wondered about how it all worked together.  Here is an excerpt of my message to her:

I have no answers for you about the "whys." I ask them myself sometimes. Theologically, I suppose one could debate about a fallen world and God remaining true and submissive to his own laws, but in the end words and discussions really don't provide the comfort and healing that is needed instead.

There will be a point in your life that you will probably wonder about how, if God is so powerful and can do anything, why he would let young children get (and die of) cancer, or why bad things happen, or why if you prayed you didn’t get the answer you wanted.  If you don’t get to that point in your life, rest assured that people you care about will.  So, I wanted to tell you what I have been led to believe, which has comforted me in times of crisis and hopefully will empower you to comfort yourself and your friends.

Simply, look at the heart of the person (or yourself) as to why the question is being asked.  I have found that the person asking the “why” question usually falls into 2 camps:  the person is angry and hurting, or the person is humbly reflecting on the mystery of the nature of God.  Mostly, people fall into the former category.  I will tell you, though, that it has been my experience that the person will not be helped by the answer to that question.  They (or you) are deluding themselves if they think it will take away the pain.  Sometimes, the person is looking for a reason to hate God and just wants to finally have a reason, because deep down they know the academic answer (which I cover in my next blog).  The actual action that needs to happen is to come alongside the one you love and tend to the hurt, and the question becomes a non-issue because the real need the person has is being tended to. 

Practically, here are some things you can say to your loved one who is really struggling:

  • You know, I ask the same thing sometimes!  I don’t have an answer for you right now, but I care and would like to walk through your pain with you.
  • I don’t feel as if I can really talk about that with you right now.  But could we spend some time together over coffee?
  • I can tell this really bothers you and makes you [sad/upset/angry].  I don’t blame you…it certainly is a good question.  Just know I care that you are [sad/upset/angry]. 
Love,